| 2020 | Vanessa Rodriguez | Iona College |
| 2015 | Chidibere Iloka | Mercer County Community College/Kean University |
| 2015 | Mike Wherley | Rider University |
| 2014 | Travis Ward | Rowan University/Greenville Triumph/Michigan Stars |
| 2013 | Lendee Henry | Drew University |
| 2013 | Obinna Iloka | Mercer County Community College |
| 2013 | Mark Dorbor | Monroe Jr. College (NY) |
| 2013 | Charles Wheaton | Monroe Jr. College (NY) |
| 2012 | Robbie Bednar | Mercer County Community College/Georgian Court University |
| 2012 | Gregorio D. Perri | The College of New Jersey |
| 2011 | Pat Seiler | Albright College |
| 2011 | Connor Koellner | Albright College |
| 2011 | Winston Cephas | Bucks County Community College |
| 2011 | David Strama | Mercer County Community College |
| 2011 | Brendan Moffat | Mercer County Community College |
| 2011 | Romy Behary | Mercer County Community College |
| 2011 | Valdo Jean Baptiste | Mercer County Communtity College/Philadelphia University |
| 2011 | Justin Ward | Quinnipiac University |
| 2011 | Emmanuel Temeh | St. Josephs University |
| 2011 | Ross Caruso | Widener University |
| 2010 | Christopher Bette | Albright College |
| 2010 | Michael Bette | Albright College |
| 2010 | Christopher Indyk | Albright College |
| 2010 | Rob Brown | Albright College |
| 2010 | Dean Search | Arcadia University |
| 2010 | Doug Cambridge | Concordia University |
| 2010 | Sean Parno | Mercer County Community College |
| 2010 | Precious Iloka | Mercer County Community College |
| 2010 | Laurence Laurenti | Mercer County Community College |
| 2010 | Kyle Bijou | Mercer County Community College/TCNJ |
| 2009 | Sascha Haecker | Mercer County Community College/Marymount California University |
| 2009 | Jonathan Majoros | Muehlenberg College |
| 2009 | Ryan Frantz | Widener University |
| 2008 | Nicholas Antonellos | Elizabethtown College |
| 2007 | Thomas Carr | Mercer County Community College |
| 2006 | Allessandro Giaquinto | Mercer County Community College |
| 2004 | Dan Kroslin | Stockton State College |
| 1996 | Bryan D. Fisher | Gettysburg College |
| 1995 | Patrick Snyder | Ursinus College/Mercer County Community College |
| 1995 | Morgan Blackwell | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1995 | Greg Kroll | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1995 | Bill Deni | Colgate University |
| 1994 | Bill George | Emory University |
| 1991 | Geoff Bennett | Hartwick College |
| 1990 | David Maly | American University |
| 1990 | Paul Meyer | USMA – West Point |
| 1989 | Shawn Gardiner | Mercer County CC / Lock Haven University |
| 1985 | Brian Matson | Pace University & American International College of London |
| 1981 | Tom Rafferty | Loyola College (Baltimore) / Houston Dynamo / Nottingham Forrest |
| 1980 | Paul Bette | New Jersey Institute of Technology |
| 1979 | Nick Wiener Jr. | Univ. of Maryland/Temple University |
| 1970 | Andy Polascak | Mercer County Community College |
| 1969 | Bob Smith | Rider College/Phil. Atoms, NY Cosmos, US Soccer National Hall of Fame |
| 1968 | Peter Lindauer Jr. | Mercer County C.C. – First Team all American 1969 & 1970, Breiderach 09 (Germany), Philadelphia Atoms |
| 1967 | Dan Knox | Steinert graduate, played for Mercer County Community College |
| 1962 | Al Cowell | Hamilton West HS, played for Rensaleer Polytechnic Institute |
